diff --git a/src/Resources/Locales/de_DE.axaml b/src/Resources/Locales/de_DE.axaml
index 276f44e8..25b54c60 100644
--- a/src/Resources/Locales/de_DE.axaml
+++ b/src/Resources/Locales/de_DE.axaml
@@ -713,7 +713,6 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitTip" xml:space="preserve">Klick-Ereignis auslösen</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitToEdit" xml:space="preserve">Commit (Bearbeitung)</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitWithAutoStage" xml:space="preserve">Alle Änderungen stagen und committen</x:String>
-  <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithoutFiles" xml:space="preserve">Leerer Commit erkannt! Fortfahren (--allow-empty)?</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts" xml:space="preserve">KONFLIKTE ERKANNT</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts.Resolved" xml:space="preserve">DATEI KONFLIKTE GELÖST</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.IncludeUntracked" xml:space="preserve">NICHT-VERFOLGTE DATEIEN INKLUDIEREN</x:String>
diff --git a/src/Resources/Locales/en_US.axaml b/src/Resources/Locales/en_US.axaml
index 97b2a832..8645cd96 100644
--- a/src/Resources/Locales/en_US.axaml
+++ b/src/Resources/Locales/en_US.axaml
@@ -177,6 +177,9 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfigureWorkspace" xml:space="preserve">Workspaces</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfigureWorkspace.Color" xml:space="preserve">Color</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfigureWorkspace.Restore" xml:space="preserve">Restore tabs on startup</x:String>
+  <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.Message" xml:space="preserve">Empty commit detected! Do you want to continue (--allow-empty) or stage all then commit?</x:String>
+  <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.Continue" xml:space="preserve">CONTINUE</x:String>
+  <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.StageAllThenCommit" xml:space="preserve">STAGE ALL &amp; COMMIT</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConventionalCommit" xml:space="preserve">Conventional Commit Helper</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConventionalCommit.BreakingChanges" xml:space="preserve">Breaking Change:</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConventionalCommit.ClosedIssue" xml:space="preserve">Closed Issue:</x:String>
@@ -721,7 +724,6 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitToEdit" xml:space="preserve">Commit (Edit)</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitWithAutoStage" xml:space="preserve">Stage all changes and commit</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithFilter">You have staged {0} file(s) but only {1} file(s) displayed ({2} files are filtered out). Do you want to continue?</x:String>
-  <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithoutFiles" xml:space="preserve">Empty commit detected! Do you want to continue (--allow-empty)?</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts" xml:space="preserve">CONFLICTS DETECTED</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts.Resolved" xml:space="preserve">FILE CONFLICTS ARE RESOLVED</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.IncludeUntracked" xml:space="preserve">INCLUDE UNTRACKED FILES</x:String>
diff --git a/src/Resources/Locales/es_ES.axaml b/src/Resources/Locales/es_ES.axaml
index e6968560..e2af0860 100644
--- a/src/Resources/Locales/es_ES.axaml
+++ b/src/Resources/Locales/es_ES.axaml
@@ -724,7 +724,6 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitTip" xml:space="preserve">Activar evento de clic</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitToEdit" xml:space="preserve">Commit (Editar)</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitWithAutoStage" xml:space="preserve">Stagear todos los cambios y commit</x:String>
-  <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithoutFiles" xml:space="preserve">¡Commit vacío detectado! ¿Quieres continuar (--allow-empty)?</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts" xml:space="preserve">CONFLICTOS DETECTADOS</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts.Resolved" xml:space="preserve">LOS CONFLICTOS DE ARCHIVOS ESTÁN RESUELTOS</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.IncludeUntracked" xml:space="preserve">INCLUIR ARCHIVOS NO RASTREADOS</x:String>
diff --git a/src/Resources/Locales/fr_FR.axaml b/src/Resources/Locales/fr_FR.axaml
index ac2ed8b8..83d590f5 100644
--- a/src/Resources/Locales/fr_FR.axaml
+++ b/src/Resources/Locales/fr_FR.axaml
@@ -726,7 +726,6 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitTip" xml:space="preserve">Trigger click event</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitToEdit" xml:space="preserve">Commit (Modifier)</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitWithAutoStage" xml:space="preserve">Indexer tous les changements et commit</x:String>
-  <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithoutFiles" xml:space="preserve">Un commit vide a été détecté ! Voulez-vous continuer (--allow-empty) ?</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts" xml:space="preserve">CONFLITS DÉTECTÉS</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts.Resolved" xml:space="preserve">LES CONFLITS DE FICHIER SONT RÉSOLUS</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.IncludeUntracked" xml:space="preserve">INCLURE LES FICHIERS NON-SUIVIS</x:String>
diff --git a/src/Resources/Locales/it_IT.axaml b/src/Resources/Locales/it_IT.axaml
index 95647101..59bf3028 100644
--- a/src/Resources/Locales/it_IT.axaml
+++ b/src/Resources/Locales/it_IT.axaml
@@ -723,7 +723,6 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitTip" xml:space="preserve">Attiva evento click</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitToEdit" xml:space="preserve">Commit (Modifica)</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitWithAutoStage" xml:space="preserve">Stage di tutte le modifiche e fai il commit</x:String>
-  <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithoutFiles" xml:space="preserve">Trovato un commit vuoto! Vuoi continuare (--allow-empty)?</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts" xml:space="preserve">CONFLITTI RILEVATI</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts.Resolved" xml:space="preserve">CONFLITTI NEI FILE RISOLTI</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.IncludeUntracked" xml:space="preserve">INCLUDI FILE NON TRACCIATI</x:String>
diff --git a/src/Resources/Locales/ja_JP.axaml b/src/Resources/Locales/ja_JP.axaml
index 91cefbac..fe643b5e 100644
--- a/src/Resources/Locales/ja_JP.axaml
+++ b/src/Resources/Locales/ja_JP.axaml
@@ -722,7 +722,6 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitTip" xml:space="preserve">クリックイベントをトリガー</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitToEdit" xml:space="preserve">コミット (Edit)</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitWithAutoStage" xml:space="preserve">すべての変更をステージしてコミット</x:String>
-  <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithoutFiles" xml:space="preserve">空のコミットが検出されました。続行しますか？ (--allow-empty)</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts" xml:space="preserve">競合が検出されました</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts.Resolved" xml:space="preserve">ファイルの競合は解決されました</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.IncludeUntracked" xml:space="preserve">追跡されていないファイルを含める</x:String>
diff --git a/src/Resources/Locales/pt_BR.axaml b/src/Resources/Locales/pt_BR.axaml
index 09b78c31..3caac3cc 100644
--- a/src/Resources/Locales/pt_BR.axaml
+++ b/src/Resources/Locales/pt_BR.axaml
@@ -657,7 +657,6 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitMessageHelper" xml:space="preserve">Modelo/Históricos</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitTip" xml:space="preserve">Acionar evento de clique</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitWithAutoStage" xml:space="preserve">Preparar todas as mudanças e commitar</x:String>
-  <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithoutFiles" xml:space="preserve">Commit vazio detectado! Deseja continuar (--allow-empty)?</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts" xml:space="preserve">CONFLITOS DETECTADOS</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts.Resolved" xml:space="preserve">CONFLITOS DE ARQUIVO RESOLVIDOS</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.IncludeUntracked" xml:space="preserve">INCLUIR ARQUIVOS NÃO RASTREADOS</x:String>
diff --git a/src/Resources/Locales/ru_RU.axaml b/src/Resources/Locales/ru_RU.axaml
index e778af86..b26532ae 100644
--- a/src/Resources/Locales/ru_RU.axaml
+++ b/src/Resources/Locales/ru_RU.axaml
@@ -725,7 +725,6 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitTip" xml:space="preserve">Запустить событие щелчка</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitToEdit" xml:space="preserve">Зафиксировать (Редактировать)</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitWithAutoStage" xml:space="preserve">Подготовить все изменения и зафиксировать</x:String>
-  <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithoutFiles" xml:space="preserve">Обнаружена пустая ревизия! Вы хотите продолжить (--allow-empty)?</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts" xml:space="preserve">ОБНАРУЖЕНЫ КОНФЛИКТЫ</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts.Resolved" xml:space="preserve">КОНФЛИКТЫ ФАЙЛОВ РАЗРЕШЕНЫ</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.IncludeUntracked" xml:space="preserve">ВКЛЮЧИТЬ НЕОТСЛЕЖИВАЕМЫЕ ФАЙЛЫ</x:String>
diff --git a/src/Resources/Locales/zh_CN.axaml b/src/Resources/Locales/zh_CN.axaml
index c1cbcc77..a2bde6f8 100644
--- a/src/Resources/Locales/zh_CN.axaml
+++ b/src/Resources/Locales/zh_CN.axaml
@@ -181,6 +181,9 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfigureWorkspace" xml:space="preserve">工作区</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfigureWorkspace.Color" xml:space="preserve">颜色</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfigureWorkspace.Restore" xml:space="preserve">启动时恢复打开的仓库</x:String>
+  <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.Message" xml:space="preserve">提交未包含变更文件！是否继续(--allow-empty)或是自动暂存所有变更并提交？</x:String>
+  <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.Continue" xml:space="preserve">确认继续</x:String>
+  <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.StageAllThenCommit" xml:space="preserve">自动暂存并提交</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConventionalCommit" xml:space="preserve">规范化提交信息生成</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConventionalCommit.BreakingChanges" xml:space="preserve">破坏性更新：</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConventionalCommit.ClosedIssue" xml:space="preserve">关闭的ISSUE：</x:String>
@@ -726,7 +729,6 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitToEdit" xml:space="preserve">提交（修改原始提交）</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitWithAutoStage" xml:space="preserve">自动暂存所有变更并提交</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithFilter" xml:space="preserve">当前有 {0} 个文件在暂存区中，但仅显示了 {1} 个文件（{2} 个文件被过滤掉了），是否继续提交？</x:String>
-  <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithoutFiles" xml:space="preserve">提交未包含变更文件！是否继续(--allow-empty)？</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts" xml:space="preserve">检测到冲突</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts.Resolved" xml:space="preserve">文件冲突已解决</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.IncludeUntracked" xml:space="preserve">显示未跟踪文件</x:String>
diff --git a/src/Resources/Locales/zh_TW.axaml b/src/Resources/Locales/zh_TW.axaml
index 34dac155..571f9376 100644
--- a/src/Resources/Locales/zh_TW.axaml
+++ b/src/Resources/Locales/zh_TW.axaml
@@ -181,6 +181,9 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfigureWorkspace" xml:space="preserve">工作區</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfigureWorkspace.Color" xml:space="preserve">顏色</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfigureWorkspace.Restore" xml:space="preserve">啟動時還原上次開啟的存放庫</x:String>
+  <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.Message" xml:space="preserve">未包含任何檔案變更! 您是否仍要提交 (--allow-empty)或者自動暫存全部變更並提交?</x:String>
+  <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.Continue" xml:space="preserve">确认继续</x:String>
+  <x:String x:Key="Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.StageAllThenCommit" xml:space="preserve">自动暂存并提交</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConventionalCommit" xml:space="preserve">產生約定式提交訊息</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConventionalCommit.BreakingChanges" xml:space="preserve">破壞性變更:</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.ConventionalCommit.ClosedIssue" xml:space="preserve">關閉的 Issue:</x:String>
@@ -725,7 +728,6 @@
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitToEdit" xml:space="preserve">提交 (修改原始提交)</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.CommitWithAutoStage" xml:space="preserve">自動暫存全部變更並提交</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithFilter" xml:space="preserve">您已暫存 {0} 檔案，但只顯示 {1} 檔案 ({2} 檔案被篩選器隱藏)。您要繼續嗎？</x:String>
-  <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithoutFiles" xml:space="preserve">未包含任何檔案變更! 您是否仍要提交 (--allow-empty)?</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts" xml:space="preserve">檢測到衝突</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.Conflicts.Resolved" xml:space="preserve">檔案衝突已解決</x:String>
   <x:String x:Key="Text.WorkingCopy.IncludeUntracked" xml:space="preserve">顯示未追蹤檔案</x:String>
diff --git a/src/ViewModels/ConfirmEmptyCommit.cs b/src/ViewModels/ConfirmEmptyCommit.cs
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..71d1f00c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/src/ViewModels/ConfirmEmptyCommit.cs
@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
+using System;
+
+namespace SourceGit.ViewModels
+{
+    public class ConfirmEmptyCommit
+    {
+        public bool HasLocalChanges
+        {
+            get;
+            private set;
+        }
+
+        public ConfirmEmptyCommit(bool hasLocalChanges, Action<bool> onSure)
+        {
+            HasLocalChanges = hasLocalChanges;
+            _onSure = onSure;
+        }
+
+        public void StageAllThenCommit()
+        {
+            _onSure?.Invoke(true);
+        }
+
+        public void Continue()
+        {
+            _onSure?.Invoke(false);
+        }
+
+        private Action<bool> _onSure;
+    }
+}
diff --git a/src/ViewModels/WorkingCopy.cs b/src/ViewModels/WorkingCopy.cs
index 784328cc..83813f39 100644
--- a/src/ViewModels/WorkingCopy.cs
+++ b/src/ViewModels/WorkingCopy.cs
@@ -1679,12 +1679,11 @@ namespace SourceGit.ViewModels
             {
                 if ((autoStage && _count == 0) || (!autoStage && _staged.Count == 0))
                 {
-                    var confirmMessage = App.Text("WorkingCopy.ConfirmCommitWithoutFiles");
-                    App.OpenDialog(new Views.ConfirmCommit()
+                    App.OpenDialog(new Views.ConfirmEmptyCommit()
                     {
-                        DataContext = new ConfirmCommit(confirmMessage, () =>
+                        DataContext = new ConfirmEmptyCommit(_count > 0, stageAll =>
                         {
-                            DoCommit(autoStage, autoPush, true, confirmWithFilter);
+                            DoCommit(stageAll, autoPush, true, confirmWithFilter);
                         })
                     });
 
diff --git a/src/Views/ConfirmEmptyCommit.axaml b/src/Views/ConfirmEmptyCommit.axaml
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ba51212b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/src/Views/ConfirmEmptyCommit.axaml
@@ -0,0 +1,72 @@
+<v:ChromelessWindow xmlns="https://github.com/avaloniaui"
+                    xmlns:x="http://schemas.microsoft.com/winfx/2006/xaml"
+                    xmlns:d="http://schemas.microsoft.com/expression/blend/2008"
+                    xmlns:mc="http://schemas.openxmlformats.org/markup-compatibility/2006"
+                    xmlns:v="using:SourceGit.Views"
+                    xmlns:vm="using:SourceGit.ViewModels"
+                    mc:Ignorable="d" d:DesignWidth="800" d:DesignHeight="450"
+                    x:Class="SourceGit.Views.ConfirmEmptyCommit"
+                    x:DataType="vm:ConfirmEmptyCommit"
+                    x:Name="ThisControl"
+                    Icon="/App.ico"
+                    Title="{DynamicResource Text.Warn}"
+                    SizeToContent="WidthAndHeight"
+                    CanResize="False"
+                    WindowStartupLocation="CenterOwner">
+  <Grid RowDefinitions="Auto,Auto,Auto">
+    <!-- TitleBar -->
+    <Grid Grid.Row="0" Height="28" IsVisible="{Binding !#ThisControl.UseSystemWindowFrame}">
+      <Border Background="{DynamicResource Brush.TitleBar}"
+              BorderThickness="0,0,0,1" BorderBrush="{DynamicResource Brush.Border0}"
+              PointerPressed="BeginMoveWindow"/>
+
+      <Path Width="14" Height="14"
+            Margin="10,0,0,0"
+            HorizontalAlignment="Left"
+            Data="{StaticResource Icons.Error}"
+            IsVisible="{OnPlatform True, macOS=False}"/>
+
+      <TextBlock Classes="bold"
+                 Text="{DynamicResource Text.Warn}"
+                 HorizontalAlignment="Center" VerticalAlignment="Center"
+                 IsHitTestVisible="False"/>
+
+      <v:CaptionButtons HorizontalAlignment="Right"
+                        IsCloseButtonOnly="True"
+                        IsVisible="{OnPlatform True, macOS=False}"/>
+    </Grid>
+
+    <!-- Body -->
+    <Border Grid.Row="1" Margin="16">
+      <TextBlock Text="{DynamicResource Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.Message}" MaxWidth="520" TextWrapping="Wrap"/>
+    </Border>
+
+    <!-- Buttons -->
+    <StackPanel Grid.Row="2" Margin="0,0,0,16" Orientation="Horizontal" HorizontalAlignment="Center">
+      <Button Classes="flat"
+              Height="30"
+              Margin="4,0"
+              IsVisible="{Binding HasLocalChanges}"
+              Click="StageAllThenCommit"
+              Content="{DynamicResource Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.StageAllThenCommit}"
+              HorizontalContentAlignment="Center"
+              VerticalContentAlignment="Center"/>
+
+      <Button Classes="flat"
+              Height="30"
+              Margin="4,0"
+              Click="Continue"
+              Content="{DynamicResource Text.ConfirmEmptyCommit.Continue}"
+              HorizontalContentAlignment="Center"
+              VerticalContentAlignment="Center"/>
+
+      <Button Classes="flat primary"
+              Height="30"
+              Margin="4,0"
+              Click="CloseWindow"
+              Content="{DynamicResource Text.Cancel}"
+              HorizontalContentAlignment="Center"
+              VerticalContentAlignment="Center"/>
+    </StackPanel>
+  </Grid>
+</v:ChromelessWindow>
diff --git a/src/Views/ConfirmEmptyCommit.axaml.cs b/src/Views/ConfirmEmptyCommit.axaml.cs
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..6668ee2c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/src/Views/ConfirmEmptyCommit.axaml.cs
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
+using Avalonia.Interactivity;
+
+namespace SourceGit.Views
+{
+    public partial class ConfirmEmptyCommit : ChromelessWindow
+    {
+        public ConfirmEmptyCommit()
+        {
+            InitializeComponent();
+        }
+
+        private void StageAllThenCommit(object _1, RoutedEventArgs _2)
+        {
+            (DataContext as ViewModels.ConfirmEmptyCommit)?.StageAllThenCommit();
+            Close();
+        }
+
+        private void Continue(object _1, RoutedEventArgs _2)
+        {
+            (DataContext as ViewModels.ConfirmEmptyCommit)?.Continue();
+            Close();
+        }
+
+        private void CloseWindow(object _1, RoutedEventArgs _2)
+        {
+            Close();
+        }
+    }
+}